First Date
Broadway. July 9, 2013 (first preview).
Cast: Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick(Reggie/Edgy Rocker Guy), Blake Hammond (Waiter/Therapist), Kate Loprest (Allison), BryceRyness (Gabe/Edgy British Guy).
Broadway - July 21, 2013, Matinee
Erik Ankrim (Aaron/understudy), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey)
Broadway - July 28, 2013 - Previews
Casey: Krysta Rodriquez; Aaron: Zachary Levi; Man #1: Bryce Ryness; Man #2: Kristoffer Cusick; Man #3: Blake Hammond; Woman #1: Sara Chase; Woman #2: Kate Loprest
Untracked
bwaybootlegtrading's master
First Date: 08/03/2013 (LongacreTheatre/Broadway) - Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie/Aaron's Future Son/Edgy British Guy), Kate Loprest (Allison), Bryce Ryness (Gabe/Edgy Rocker Dude), Blake Hammond (Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist)
First Date: 08/04/2013m (Longacre Theatre/Broadway) - Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie/Aaron's Future Son/Edgy British Guy), Kate Loprest (Allison/Google Girl/Reggie's Mom), Bryce Ryness (Gabe/Edgy Rocker Dude/Gilberto), Blake Hammond (Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist)
Broadway - November 10, 2013
Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Bryce Ryness (Gabe), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren), Kate Loprest (Allison).
*BC/EFA speech by Zachary Levi.
First Date - Broadway - January 5, 2014 - RAR
Cast: Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), BryceRyness (Gabe/Edgy British Guy/Gilberto), Kristoffer Cusick(Reggie/Edgy British Guy/Aaron's Future Son), Blake Hammond (Waiter/Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist), Sara Chase (Lauren/Grandma Ida/Aaron's Mother), KateLoprest (Allison/Google Girl/Reggie's Mom)
Notes: Closing Night. Zachary starts crying during the bridge of "The Things I Never Said."
Broadway. July 9, 2013 (first preview).
Cast: Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick(Reggie/Edgy Rocker Guy), Blake Hammond (Waiter/Therapist), Kate Loprest (Allison), BryceRyness (Gabe/Edgy British Guy).
Broadway - July 21, 2013, Matinee
Erik Ankrim (Aaron/understudy), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey)
Broadway - July 28, 2013 - Previews
Casey: Krysta Rodriquez; Aaron: Zachary Levi; Man #1: Bryce Ryness; Man #2: Kristoffer Cusick; Man #3: Blake Hammond; Woman #1: Sara Chase; Woman #2: Kate Loprest
Untracked
bwaybootlegtrading's master
First Date: 08/03/2013 (LongacreTheatre/Broadway) - Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie/Aaron's Future Son/Edgy British Guy), Kate Loprest (Allison), Bryce Ryness (Gabe/Edgy Rocker Dude), Blake Hammond (Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist)
First Date: 08/04/2013m (Longacre Theatre/Broadway) - Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren/Aaron's Mother), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie/Aaron's Future Son/Edgy British Guy), Kate Loprest (Allison/Google Girl/Reggie's Mom), Bryce Ryness (Gabe/Edgy Rocker Dude/Gilberto), Blake Hammond (Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist)
Broadway - November 10, 2013
Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), Bryce Ryness (Gabe), Kristoffer Cusick (Reggie), Sara Chase (Grandma Ida/Lauren), Kate Loprest (Allison).
*BC/EFA speech by Zachary Levi.
First Date - Broadway - January 5, 2014 - RAR
Cast: Zachary Levi (Aaron), Krysta Rodriguez (Casey), BryceRyness (Gabe/Edgy British Guy/Gilberto), Kristoffer Cusick(Reggie/Edgy British Guy/Aaron's Future Son), Blake Hammond (Waiter/Casey's Father/Blaze/Friendly Therapist), Sara Chase (Lauren/Grandma Ida/Aaron's Mother), KateLoprest (Allison/Google Girl/Reggie's Mom)
Notes: Closing Night. Zachary starts crying during the bridge of "The Things I Never Said."